Who this applies to
California splits retention between two codes, and both reach below the prime contract.
On public works, Public Contract Code § 7201 limits the retention a public entity withholds from the original contractor, that the original contractor withholds from any subcontractor, and that a subcontractor withholds from the tier beneath it [7]. Section 7107 of the same code sets the release rules, and it binds the original contractor as well as the entity [6].
On private works of improvement, Civil Code §§ 8810 to 8822 cover retention an owner withholds from a direct contractor and retention a direct contractor withholds from a subcontractor [1].
Neither side can be bargained away. Waiving the private article by contract is against public policy [5], no party may require another to waive § 7201 [7], and an attempted waiver of § 7107 is void [6].
What the rule says
Public retention is capped at 5% of each payment and at 5% of the contract price in total [7], and no lower tier may be held to a higher percentage than the public entity holds from the original contractor. Private retention has no statutory percentage at all. What the two sides share is a deadline, 45 days after completion for a private owner [2] and 60 days for a public entity [6], backed by a 2% monthly charge on late money [4] [6].
How to comply
Public contracts
- Check the percentage. A retention clause above 5% [7] needs one of the two exceptions in § 7201: a pre-bid finding by the awarding entity that the project is substantially complex, with the basis explained in the bid documents, or a subcontractor that cannot or will not furnish performance and payment bonds after written pre-bid notice under § 4108(c) [7].
- Pin down completion. "Completion" means occupation or beneficial use with labor stopped, acceptance by the agency, a 100-day [6] stoppage beyond the contractor's control, or a 30-day [6] stoppage with a recorded notice of cessation or completion.
- Count the days. The entity releases retention within 60 days [6] of completion. A state agency retaining no more than 125% [6] of the estimated value of the remaining work has 90 days [6]. In a dispute, the entity may keep from the final payment up to 150% [6] of the disputed amount.
- Pass it down. Once the original contractor receives retention, each subcontractor's share is due within 7 days [6]. That deadline belongs to the original contractor, not to the entity.
- Swap the cash. Section 22300 lets the contractor substitute securities, or an escrow, for retention held in cash [8].
- If it is late. Improperly withheld retention draws a charge of 2% per month [6] in place of interest, and the winner of a collection action recovers attorney's fees and costs.
Private jobs
The contract sets the percentage; the statute sets the timing.
- Owner's deadline. Retention is due to the direct contractor within 45 days [2] after completion of the work of improvement. Retention on any part that will become a public entity's property may wait for that entity's acceptance.
- Subcontractor's share. After the direct contractor is paid, it has 10 days [3] to pass each subcontractor its share (a separate pass-down deadline, not the owner's release date).
- Disputes. In a good faith dispute the owner may keep from final payment no more than 150% [2] of the disputed amount, and a direct contractor withholding from a subcontractor is held to the same 150% [3].
- Late payment. Wrongfully withheld retention carries a 2% monthly penalty [4] in place of interest, plus costs and reasonable attorney's fees for the prevailing party in a collection action.
What changed recently
The private deadlines in § 8812 were added by SB 189 (Stats. 2010, Ch. 697, § 20), effective January 1, 2011 and operative July 1, 2012 [2]. The 5% public ceiling applies to contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2012 [7].
Related
- Retainage calculator: pay-application math at the contract's rate.
- Retainage laws by state: California's deadlines next to other states'.